Lost Lake

Comments about Lost Lake

baxter's island

June 8, 2019, 5:32 AM

the chicago tiki bar to go to. just wonderful.

paigeelizabeth3660

paigeelizabeth3660 has visited Lost Lake.

June 7, 2019, 3:11 AM

I was very impressed with the drinks, particularly their larger scale shareable drinks. Left with several very nice swizzle sticks. Decor was sort of middle of the pack. Dark lighting, nice atmosphere, but not a ton of true tiki pieces. Check came with a nice post card.

TikiTuan

TikiTuan has visited Lost Lake.

June 4, 2019, 9:10 PM

Tiki Tuan’s Wing Only Review:

Great wings. There’s a strong fish sauce smell, but just a slight hint in the actual flavor. It’s char-grilled a bit more than your average wing, but adds a good crisp.

If there was ever a Vietnamese style wing, this would be it.

Trader Anne

Trader Anne has visited Lost Lake.

June 4, 2019, 8:42 PM

I liked this place. I preferred it over 3 Dots because it felt more welcoming, despite a definite hipster vibe. I was the only person there who seemed excited about tiki, which was disappointing. Overall, the food and drinks were delicious and the bar is a cool place to hang out.

Stacy

Stacy has visited Lost Lake.

March 11, 2019, 10:49 PM

Very fun and can see why it’s popular. While if I had to choose between this and three dots, 3 dots would win, but I’m glad we got to visit. Agree with other reviews that this place is low key and pretty unpretentious. Had the very popular and instagram worthy banana Daiquiri and it was great. Sorry collectors, they don’t sell mugs, but worth visiting for the solid drinks and food.

themeperks

themeperks has visited Lost Lake.

March 5, 2019, 9:10 AM

The three most important characteristics of tiki bars, in no particular order, are drinks, food, and ambiance.

Lost Lake scores particularly high in the drinks category, with some of the most complex, subtle, varied and interesting cocktails I've encountered. Also, be sure to request the rum list. Although it has not been kept up to date, there are hundreds of interesting rums to choose from. About half are available, and there are many more that haven't been added to the list. If you're a true tiki fan, then rare rums are a particular delight.

Most tiki bars offer the same pseudo-Polynesian fare, so it was interesting to see the menu at Lost Lake, which avoids all of that, and has some truly nice offerings. I hear from regulars that the food has improved over the years, and we certainly liked everything we tried. The Orange Sesame Cabbage was a particularly good slaw, and didn't even need the chicken we added. Pork dumplings and chicken wings were also both good. Our favorite was the green chili dip, which had just the right spice level. It was served with crispy wontons, radishes, and sweet potato slices. It was so good we had two orders.

The weakest aspect of Lost Lake is the decor, which is okay, but not at the spectacular level of Three Dots and a Dash or the Mai Kai in Fort Lauderdale. The bar area theming is little more than banana leaf wallpaper, but the farther you go back the more interesting it gets. The back room has rock walls and puffer fish light fixtures.

For tiki mug collectors note that they offer unbranded tiki mugs; only the glassware carries the Lost Lake branding.

Service was friendly and attentive. If you're a tiki drink fan, Lost Lake is definitely a place that should be on your list to visit.

Kimberry226

Kimberry226 has visited Lost Lake.

October 13, 2018, 6:20 PM

This is the best place ever!!!!

Torgny

Torgny has visited Lost Lake.

September 5, 2018, 3:08 PM

While Lost Lake is quite a drive from downtown Chicago, especially during rush hour, we made the trek early one Thursday evening. Though it wasn’t what we expected, we had a good time and it’s certainly worth a visit.

Everyone was very friendly and attentive. The hostess greeted us immediately and led us to a table and our waitress arrived in due course. Though tiki cocktails can be complicated to make and can take a long time to order and receive, that wasn’t the case here at all. We never had any difficulty ordering and everything arrived at our table quickly. While there were only about 12 drink options (excluding a handful of larger shared drinks) the drinks were all interesting, flavorful, and very nicely decorated.

If we were disappointed in anything it was in the décor. The bar was very nice, and tastefully decorated, but it seemed more like a hipster bar in Florida than a tiki bar. The walls were covered in palm or banana leaf wallpaper, one wall had the bar’s name in red neon, there were some Polynesian fish trap lights, and there was bamboo here and there. But no tiki statues, carvings, water elements (other than an aquarium which seemed a bit out of place and in which we didn’t see any fish), or other Polynesian décor. And while the large front window made the bar feel light and airy, it prevented us from pretending we were anywhere but a bar in a fairly industrial area of Chicago. I also, oddly, don’t recall any music at all, which either means there wasn’t any or that it was very quiet and at least wasn’t jarring and out of place.

The food we tried was tasty, but the options seemed a bit odd for a tiki bar, consisting mostly of banh mi and noodle and rice bowls rather than of Polynesian food or bar snacks. I don’t know about others, but a rice bowl just sounds wrong to me as the food to have with a tiki drink.

It was also disappointing to learn that Lost Lake doesn’t sell any logo tiki mugs. All they sell are the standard, non-logo, tiki mugs you can get virtually anywhere. They do sell logo Collins and Mai Tai glasses (we did end up buying one of those), but they aren’t at all the same thing as a logo tiki mug. Deciding not to sell logo mugs seems like an odd choice for a tiki bar that presumably could not only make extra money from such sales but could also obtain free advertising from them, but it’s their business, not mine.

All in all a very pleasant place to get a very well-made tiki drink. Just not a place to suspend your disbelief and pretend you’re in the islands, taking a break from the real world.

Tikisteffie

Tikisteffie has visited Lost Lake.

August 11, 2018, 2:51 PM

We love it If we wood live in Chicago we wood go ther al the time !!!!

WFlourance

WFlourance has visited Lost Lake.

July 6, 2018, 8:18 AM

Went to Lost Lake on a Tuesday Night. Definitely a ways from downtown Chicago but completely worth it. It's certainly on the smaller side and the bar staff was thin for bustling crowd within. Everyone was super friendly! You can tell these bar tenders have a lot of enthusiasm for what they do. The menu is gigantic and beautifully designed. They have an overwhelming amount of delicious house specialties and takes on tiki classics as well as all the traditional drinks. I had the No Bye / No Aloha but also tried the Banana Daiquiri and Glassquiri which were both incredible. The decor was amazing as well, the bright neon pink sign adds a warm glow to the room, the wall paper makes it feel trendy and tropical, and the layout makes you gather around the bar for a more social, easygoing visit.

The bar staff was incredibly friendly and were super enthused to give me a handful of swizzle stick souvenirs before I left, hardly had to ask. I could see where some tiki enthusiasts might see Lost Lake as a tiki bar for hipsters, but the drinks and service were so damn good I'd say that's hardly anything to complain about.

Tikiwolverine

Tikiwolverine has visited Lost Lake.

July 2, 2018, 2:34 PM

Tiki for the hipster crowd, more laid back, casual feel. Today's nod to tiki furnished with Cost Plus World Market mugs. A little disappointed they didn't have their own tiki mugs to offer, an exclusive Lost Lake mug. Took home a glass instead. The place was packed, the drinks were well done and the vibe was chill.

Drinkbot

Drinkbot has visited Lost Lake.

May 28, 2018, 3:36 PM

Highly positive experience! Visited on May 26, 2018 at about 6:30pm and sat at the bar. We were lucky to get seats because the place was already full. Julia was our bartender. The whole team was highly professional and efficient, mixing super tasty drinks with attractive garnish, making a great presentation. Also tried the dumplings, which were the best I’ve ever tasted. My compliments to the staff!

Raider273

Raider273 has visited Lost Lake.

March 17, 2018, 10:19 AM

Wife and I visited the evening of Thursday, March 8, 2018. Hit Lost Lake and Three Dots the same day- Doesn't get much better than that! Arrived at opening and sat at the bar. Place filled up quickly but our bartender, who had just moved from Milwaukee, made time to chat about the drinks and our upcoming visit to her hometown.

Drinks, service, and music were great, a true tiki bar vibe. I'm a believer that tiki bars are best dark and was a little disappointed about the amount of light coming through the front frosted windows. Problem went away at sundown, but it's a little hard to imagine being transported to a tropical paradise in the light of day. Would also have appreciated a more authentic selection of tiki mug(s)

Review might seem a little negative, but that's not my intent. Lost Lake is tiki bar in the true sense of the phrase; high praise indeed.

Mmtreu

January 25, 2018, 9:17 AM

Following LL’s phenomenally creative and immersive 2017 Christmas drinks and decor, the bar has introduced a brand new menu. It is the result of a year’s worth of drink design and experimentation. The result is a resounding success; the new menu includes many old favorites from Lost Lake’s first years, but a vast array of brand new inventions and a surprising number of group drinks with dazzling new vessels. This reveals a spectacular dedication to the customer experience. LL continues to invest a great deal in drink appearance., much more than other bars that have achieved higher ratings. And the taste experience continues to impress, with exotic combinations, unusual components, and satisfying balance.

GeekyTiki

GeekyTiki is a regular at Lost Lake, and is usually there early on Sunday evenings.

November 18, 2017, 8:48 AM

Another Lost Lake Update:
Beginning Thanksgiving weekend and running through December, Lost Lake turns into Sippin' Santa's Surf Shack. The bar will be decked out in tinsel and lights and they will serve an X-mas inspired menu of tropical concoctions in holiday appropriate mugs (I HIGHLY recommend the "On Christmas Island" if its available this year). I definitely encourage anyone in the Chicago area through December to stop in and check it out; its pretty great (I've uploaded an image from last year).

GeekyTiki

GeekyTiki is a regular at Lost Lake, and is usually there early on Sunday evenings.

October 18, 2017, 2:07 PM

An update on FOOD and the NEW BAR SPACE
Happy to say that as of late August, Lost lake has two exciting developments. The first is that they are once again offering food after the electrical fire of 2016 destroyed the kitchen of Thank You, their Chinese take-out inspired food location next door. The new menu offers several small plates inspired by various Asian and Polynesian cuisines. More info and a link to the menu itself is available on DNAinfo Chicago who profiled the new food options in August. The second bit of news is that the former space occupied by Thank You is now a bar within a bar called Stranger in Paradise. This small space will be utilized whenever they have guest bartenders from other Tiki spots as well as a venue for special "pop-up" bars for their own employees to try out "Strange" new drink concoctions, typically around a unifying theme. On nights without a visiting bartender or one of these pop-up events, it offers some much needed extra space to a the frustratingly small and perpetually busy main bar area. I stopped by Stranger in Paradise the week after it opened on a Saturday. It wasn't having one of its themed pop-ups nor was it hosting another bar, so I happily ordered my usual (the Heaven is a Place is FANTASTIC!) while my wife ordered their delicious namesake cocktail and we split an order of RangUni (think crab rangoon, but with Uni). The food was great, the drinks perfect as always, and the vibe of the Stranger in Paradise area was good. Two things to be aware of if you choose to sit in the Stranger in Paradise side of the bar, though: Its a lot brighter than the main space (small and lit by their logo in neon script on one wall) and, most importantly, there is only ONE bartender on that side (again, its small). The drinks were delicious and she was friendly and attentive, but drinks were definitely slower to come out than they probably would have been at the main bar which typically has three or more people mixing. This isn't a criticism, its a small space so they just can't fit more than one person back there, just be aware of it going in and don't fault the bartender if your Curative Vibration is a little slow to arrive. They're doing the best they can! That said, Lost Lake is great, as always, and I hope you'll visit if you're in Chicago. Its worth the trip!

NeilSmith

NeilSmith has visited Lost Lake.

September 23, 2017, 11:16 AM

I visited Lost Lake twice whilst on my Chicago vacation, the first time my Wife and I visited, we had already been to Three Dots and a Dash so had already had a couple of cocktails, it was early evening on the Saturday night at Lost Lake and was able to get two seats at the bar, the Bartender was excellent, my Wife had a Lost Lake and I had a Banana Daiquiri the drinks were good, however I think the Bar Manager could have made so much more effort, we picked up Mugs, Glasses and a few swizzles. On our second visit on the Monday we went just after opening, the Bar Tender seemed disinterested. I was very disappointed, and thought I'd wasted my money on the Uber to get there.

tikiglees

tikiglees has visited Lost Lake.

July 30, 2017, 2:40 PM

Visited on Saturday night... arrived just in time as it was a full house by the time we left. extremely well crafted drinks and served us off the menu as well - service with a bit of an attitude but still fun. Great time - its only a few years old, but feels like the bar has been there for decades

GeekyTiki

GeekyTiki is a regular at Lost Lake, and is usually there early on Sunday evenings.

May 29, 2017, 7:42 PM

Full disclosure: Lost Lake is one of my favorite places in the world so take this review with a grain of salt. The drinks are amazing and the staff is always willing to offer recommendations or venture off menu if you're really itching for a classic drink that isn't on the menu. I know they sometimes get knocked points for lack of Tikis or music that may stray into Tiki-adjacent styles rather than strictly Exotica (you'll hear Martin Denny, but might hear some Desmond Dekker too which isn't really anything to complain about), Most of all, Lost Lake and Paul McGee are very much aiming for the same kind of "explorer's/adventurer's bar at the edge of the unknown" that Don and Vic were trying to recreate and they are succeeding. Those of us who suffer through Chicago winters will always be thankful for this little island of escape.

oneparticularparrot

oneparticularparrot has visited Lost Lake.

May 25, 2017, 7:21 PM

Visited on a Thursday in May. Nice crowd but not packed. Excellent cocktails and mood. Loved hearing hula and some exotica. Friendly staff and patrons. Challenging for Uber to find - lol. Subtle exterior.

Kahiki Guy

Kahiki Guy has visited Lost Lake.

April 26, 2017, 11:48 AM

Fun place that knows how to make a Tiki cocktail. But with Paul McGee running things, what do you expect.

Dr. McTiki

Dr. McTiki has visited Lost Lake.

December 20, 2016, 7:57 PM

Had just enough time before my flight out of O'Hare to stop here on my way to the airport and I was not disappointed!

Just a quick walk from the "L," even in sub-freezing temperatures, completely worth the trip.

I visited during the Sippin' Santa's Surf Shack pop up and loved the On Christmas Island - a great tiki drink served from Santa Claus' pants. I also got to try the Tic Tac Taxi - if you're willing to try a frozen drink it's an excellent choice.

Jackievonspanks

September 17, 2016, 9:13 PM

Super sad, went to check out this place on a Saturday. They were blasting hip hop music. Sorry don't have time to wait in a line for that.

Tiare

Tiare has visited Lost Lake.

July 3, 2016, 10:42 AM

I went in May, on a Thursday night around 5pm so wasn't too croweded yet. Was able to score the last table. Didn't get any food but tried about 4 different drinks. All good. I liked the decor and service was good. It is very close to the L stop so you can walk from there.

ggbj1966

ggbj1966 has visited Lost Lake.

June 6, 2016, 5:18 PM

This is a case study in neighborhood Tiki Bar.

Cheap bastard

Cheap bastard has visited Lost Lake.

March 19, 2016, 7:20 AM

Lost lake is the perfect in between kinda bar. It's not too mod and it's not a dive. It's just right. I like their souvenir cocktail glasses. It's different than just getting mugs and a whole lot cheaper! I haven't seen a rum selection like this place has in a long time. Brian the bartender told me the story about he and his sister designed the place and it is always a good feeling when the manager takes time to talk to a tourist. I went right when they opened at 4 and the place filled up fast! Parking is challenging but worth it. Great tiki bar.

Doctor Ti

Doctor Ti has visited Lost Lake.

March 5, 2016, 7:56 AM

Lost Lake may be tiny, but it's a heavyweight when it comes to exquisitely crafted tropical cocktails. After sampling over half a dozen of their creations (including some of John's on-the-spot improvisations), I can easily say that Lost Lake's bartenders compose the most delicously nuanced cocktails I've come across outside of Smuggler's Cove in San Francisco. The decor is not overly tiki, but Lost Lake makes up for it with great music, fun drink names, and excellent presentation. If you're visiting on a weekend, come right at opening (there was already a small line) and grab a seat at the bar. The food is delicious*, the drinks are divine, and the bartenders are excellent hosts.

*Caveat: avoid the two "very spicy" items on the menu. They can temporarily ruin your palate for all those wonderful tropical drinks.

cocktail_adventuring

cocktail_adventuring has visited Lost Lake.

February 29, 2016, 12:14 AM

John was an amazing bar tender. My friend and I held two stools down for close to six hours. John took us on a great off the menu trip after hour 4. He indulged our questions and curiousness. Lost Lake will be my first stop every time I am in Chicago.

Regulars and Visitors of Lost Lake

Regulars

People who go to Lost Lake at least a few times a month.

• thedrunkentiki
  Usually Sunday or Monday nights
• elliepritts
  weekdays
• Citizenskip
• GeekyTiki
  early on Sunday evenings
• Tiki Mistress
• ladybird_gem
  Right after work
• Lady Kai
  3x a month
• jhilla
  Every Sunday I'm free
• 151_
  sundays late night

Semi-Regulars

People who go to Lost Lake at least a few times a year.

• 
  Quince at Dannys
• 
  Unknown_Rangoon
• 
  BitnerDesign
• 
  Tiki Chi
• 
  JeffCleveland
• 
  rsully95
• 
  KukePuluke
• 
  Thirsty
• 
  thedrgram
• 
  Papaw
• 
  Helen Alice
• 
  TheAlum
• 
  tammylc
• 
  ChicagoTiki
• 
  Laka_Lono
• 
  roddog
• 
  Tiki Carl
• 
  Anntiki
• 
  MaikeTai
• 
  matthucke
• 
  SarntLee
• 
  TikiGreg
• 
  roxydanger
• 
  DebP
• 
  Demerara24
• 
  KillDevil
• 
  TheFuzzyMusk
• 
  KahunaCP
• 
  Leaky Tiki
• 
  smashlers
• 
  MINITiki

Visitors

People who have been to Lost Lake at least once.

• 
  Zombified
• 
  Trader Mike
• 
  Tiare
• 
  monkeyskull
• 
  Matango Derek
• 
  Rugby Matt
• 
  Lokelani
• 
  Trader Tom
• 
  NautiTiki
• 
  tikitabby
• 
  Tikinaut
• 
  aloha.taboo
• 
  pittsburgh paulie
• 
  RumRandy
• 
  SufferinSimon
• 
  KeithH
• 
  gucky
• 
  AtomicToby
• 
  Kuai Craig
• 
  Hang10tiki
• 
  bongoboy
• 
  Tiki Thomas
• 
  horgaloha
• 
  creepy tiki
• 
  sherlock2713
• 
  gooneybird
• 
  Tiki Finky
• 
  Bruce
• 
  eli
• 
  The Porkchop Express
• 
  Grog_Zombie
• 
  Whaia-Muri
• 
  skillbilly
• 
  A'Pau-ling
• 
  Silly Idol
• 
  Tikihut Honeycutt
• 
  mllekat
• 
  Jon-Tiki
• 
  TheRumTrader
• 
  Comicbookhero
• 
  Cheap bastard
• 
  retrocelt
• 
  madcow
• 
  abkidd
• 
  alohameisha
• 
  referencefox
• 
  tikiglees
• 
  boha
• 
  Enchanted Treehouse
• 
  oneparticularparrot
• 
  Pelvis
• 
  swiz
• 
  IndyEdward
• 
  Tiki Mon
• 
  drvid64
• 
  TikiEd
• 
  Adam Bomb
• 
  soldiersdisease
• 
  maxelman
• 
  Doctor Ti
• 
  cocktail_adventuring
• 
  Dr. McTiki
• 
  eric
• 
  GR8Y
• 
  rahi i'a
• 
  Martiki71
• 
  Ohhoe
• 
  ggbj1966
• 
  Farbror Fuzz
• 
  JimNeumayer
• 
  Schwafish
• 
  Drinkbot
• 
  TikiPalace
• 
  Kdrnc
• 
  davidphantomatic
• 
  erichauser
• 
  TheMeekTiki
• 
  lesamonster
• 
  mokantiki
• 
  abacab
• 
  donwestchester
• 
  Tangaroa Jefferson
• 
  Rumjourney
• 
  Cosmic Coconut
• 
  Wolftiki
• 
  Mockingbird
• 
  kylelankford
• 
  NeilSmith
• 
  Claymontgomery
• 
  mattyt
• 
  amy
• 
  1934Zombie
• 
  NinaColada
• 
  LizAtomic
• 
  erikdaniells
• 
  dominodamsel
• 
  Disarmed
• 
  AtomicLady
• 
  DaveValdez
• 
  Tiki_Will
• 
  geotiki
• 
  BeccaSchmecca
• 
  nicholasrooster
• 
  Tiki Slinger
• 
  mlee525
• 
  littlemissfelina
• 
  HinaKaluua
• 
  Mnchuck
• 
  kimmikat
• 
  scubarex
• 
  aboucher04
• 
  Raider273
• 
  GitcheeTiki
• 
  Tonga Trader
• 
  Misterkingdom
• 
  TPA2LAS
• 
  Mcg1277
• 
  Lily Starck White
• 
  Josh Yonutas
• 
  RumDrunkPirate
• 
  craigbestjr
• 
  fun4robots
• 
  jchicago
• 
  Murray
• 
  CancelledHoneymoon
• 
  Jonny
• 
  waterygrave
• 
  Laguna
• 
  Tikibaz
• 
  Bungalow Robb
• 
  TikiMichelle
• 
  miss_hilda
• 
  IvanaBlaize
• 
  fgagnon
• 
  dfpratt09
• 
  galaboutmidtown
• 
  rwallmeier
• 
  kemika_popoki
• 
  Moxietregatti
• 
  Uapu'uwai
• 
  Ggavintage
• 
  adriancardwell
• 
  Cape FM
• 
  ANTIPANTS
• 
  Tinman Tom
• 
  dmessent
• 
  TikiCatKC
• 
  go_jake
• 
  Dapper Don Juan
• 
  Tiki Kitten
• 
  Natqmerc7313
• 
  VintageVixen
• 
  Paralyzed Poly
• 
  Kahiki Guy
• 
  AWESOM-O
• 
  Missmaelaroux
• 
  Cap'nHaddock
• 
  DesertTiki
• 
  JungleBird
• 
  Cactus1932
• 
  rkseal
• 
  JDTikiPaddler
• 
  Hoosier_Yankee
• 
  Tige
• 
  sannydamet
• 
  Garrlicbread
• 
  Tiki Lindy
• 
  Ogopogotiki
• 
  Fridalupe
• 
  merdogg
• 
  SuperBigChief
• 
  unefemmejulie
• 
  LoaLaur
• 
  themeperks
• 
  AlohaEric
• 
  Haute.sauce
• 
  Bdassell
• 
  Jeff Bannow
• 
  the-moleman
• 
  Trader Jay
• 
  TikiTikiTavi
• 
  dlgreenwald
• 
  Trader Mimo
• 
  nichali
• 
  MoVengeance
• 
  sangsterrific
• 
  roa_ae_ryan
• 
  Alidactly
• 
  Frenchy
• 
  neanderthal85
• 
  Lmac
• 
  Magnum65
• 
  ApeMummy
• 
  squares
• 
  tikiobsessed
• 
  alleykatking
• 
  SweetLeilani
• 
  tikisota
• 
  ms.swizzlestick
• 
  Capt1320
• 
  WFlourance
• 
  jimbo
• 
  BarnztheTiki
• 
  Mat&Josh
• 
  Rumandbones
• 
  MichallaMarie
• 
  58_Esquire
• 
  WonderBred
• 
  DMB
• 
  Tikiwolverine
• 
  Jesse
• 
  AlohaYaz
• 
  Trader Anne
• 
  Torgny
• 
  Cutter
• 
  TikiTuan
• 
  Wyatt Magnum
• 
  theCursedislands
• 
  michigan_rummy
• 
  gomamago
• 
  KBoroniec
• 
  BobDance
• 
  cmk713
• 
  Tikisteffie
• 
  DrSchooner
• 
  Nichole917
• 
  LeiYo
• 
  Trader_Sam
• 
  Timbucktuna
• 
  okuma
• 
  GrimTiki
• 
  Ka Laki Lolo Tiki
• 
  StinkyMatt
• 
  SanDiegoMystic
• 
  RoccoSupreme
• 
  Kimberry226
• 
  RandomBear
• 
  MuddyMaeSuggins
• 
  Jay138
• 
  FujiyamaLana
• 
  gordongregory
• 
  Kona Coffee
• 
  Louie23
• 
  McLaughlin21
• 
  itz_jana
• 
  polytiki
• 
  rumamok
• 
  rumlocker
• 
  Stacy
• 
  Tiki Swizzle
• 
  guyworthy
• 
  RollingDice
• 
  Wotuka
• 
  daveduffett
• 
  SugaKane
• 
  coconutbrah
• 
  paigeelizabeth3660
• 
  sarahsb57
• 
  VinnieDuber
• 
  clntdnl